Mark Panciera

What Motivates People to Change Behavior? Start With Belief

Written by

|

Businesswoman ascending a sunlit spiral staircase in a modern building.

Key Takeaways

  • Beliefs determine whether behavior change lasts. Motivation is what drives people to change, but their beliefs about their own abilities determine whether they keep going after setbacks.
  • Intrinsic motivation tends to outlast extrinsic rewards. Rewards like bonuses can drive short-term effort, while motivation that comes from meaningful work is more likely to last.
  • Self-efficacy supports follow-through. People who believe they can succeed tend to put in more effort and keep going when progress gets difficult.
  • Limiting beliefs can be changed in three steps: identify the assumption behind a behavior, question whether it’s accurate, and replace it with a more constructive belief.
  • Leaders shape what their teams believe. Managers’ own assumptions influence how employees approach change, which makes leadership beliefs a natural starting point for organizational change.

Think about the last time you tried to change a habit, or watched someone on your team try. If you’ve ever wondered what motivates people to change behavior, you know that wanting to change and actually changing aren’t the same thing.

If you’re a leader who has tried incentives and pep talks to change how your team works, and you still watch the old habits creep back, this article is written for you.

The missing piece is likely the beliefs behind those behaviors. When you look at how beliefs shape your own actions and the way you lead, you can start creating change that actually lasts.

What Motivates People to Change Behavior?

What motivates people to change behavior is usually a mix of dissatisfaction and possibility: they realize their current approach isn’t getting them where they want to be, and they see real value in doing something different.

Often, it’s a specific moment that tips the balance, like a doctor’s warning, a tough conversation at work, or simply feeling stuck one too many times. That’s when the cost of staying the same starts to feel bigger than the effort of changing.

Getting started is only part of the picture. Whether the change lasts comes down to a few different factors, starting with what kind of motivation is driving it in the first place.

Intrinsic and Extrinsic Motivation

Motivation generally comes from two places, and the difference helps explain what drives people to keep going once a reward is off the table:

  • Intrinsic motivation comes from within. The work itself feels rewarding, like an employee who takes on a challenging project because they enjoy building new skills.
  • Extrinsic motivation comes from an outside outcome, such as a promotion, a bonus, or recognition.

Both forms of motivation can influence performance. However, intrinsic motivation tends to last longer because what drives people is the activity itself rather than an outside reward.

Self-determination theory helps explain why. Research suggests people are more likely to experience autonomous motivation when they feel capable, have meaningful choices, and have a sense of connection with others.

At work, that might mean letting employees decide how they approach a project, giving them room to build skills on the job, and making sure they feel like part of a team rather than just assigned to one. External rewards still matter, but they work best when there’s a greater sense of meaning.

What Sparks the Decision to Change

People often decide to change when something disrupts their usual way of thinking or makes a different outcome feel possible.

Some of the most common things that motivate people to reconsider their behavior include:

  • A painful experience: A missed opportunity or disappointing result makes someone recognize that their current approach isn’t working.
  • A new insight: Feedback or a different perspective helps someone understand how their behavior affects their results.
  • A meaningful reward: The possibility of advancement or another valued outcome encourages someone to make an effort.
  • A personal goal: Someone recognizes an opportunity to become more capable or achieve something important to them.

Each of these experiences can create momentum. A leader might leave a workshop feeling inspired to communicate differently, for example, only to return to familiar habits when workplace pressures increase. The initial motivation matters, but lasting change requires examining what continues to influence behavior after that motivation fades.

When Motivation Fades, Belief Decides Whether Change Lasts

Motivation can get someone started, but their underlying beliefs often decide whether they keep going.

Take two people who decide to start exercising. Both want to get healthier, but one believes they can gradually become more active, while the other has always assumed they’re just not an athletic person. Even with the same goal, they’re starting with very different expectations.

Now let’s say both have a rough week. They miss a planned workout and struggle through the next one. The first person sees it as a normal setback, but for the second, it feels like proof of what they suspected all along: they were never going to stick with it. Their motivation was real, but a belief overrode it.

This ties back to the theory of self-efficacy. Believing in your ability to accomplish something influences how much effort you put in and how willing you are to push through setbacks. That’s why what drives people to start isn’t always what helps them keep going. Without addressing the belief underneath, even a compelling reason to change can lose out to familiar patterns.

Shifting From Limiting to Liberating Beliefs

The good news is that beliefs aren’t fixed. With practice, people can learn to catch a limiting belief and replace it with one that supports the change they want to make.

The process usually looks like this:

  • Identify the assumption behind the behavior. Someone who keeps abandoning new goals might realize they believe missing one day means they’ve failed entirely.
  • Question whether it’s accurate. Does one missed workout really erase weeks of progress, or is it just an interruption they can recover from?
  • Replace it with a more liberating belief, such as: “I can make progress even when I’m not perfectly consistent.”

That new perspective makes it much easier to get back on track after a setback. Learning how to change limiting beliefs gives people a practical way to support the changes they’re motivated to make, instead of relying on enthusiasm alone.

How Do You Motivate People to Change?

You motivate people to change by creating conditions where change feels possible and by helping them recognize the beliefs that may be holding them back.

When it comes to leading employees, things that motivate people like incentives can help, but they rarely work on their own if people don’t believe their effort will make a difference. That doubt doesn’t form in a vacuum. Employees pick up a lot from how their leaders respond to setbacks, new ideas, and change itself, which means the work starts with you.

Start With Your Own Beliefs

It’s easy to focus on changing your team’s behavior without noticing how your own assumptions might be part of the problem. A manager experiencing imposter syndrome at work, for example, may doubt their ability to lead and compensate by micromanaging. Another might avoid difficult conversations, assuming conflict will damage relationships, and let small problems grow.

Recognizing these patterns requires asking yourself why certain situations consistently trigger the same responses. Understanding what drives people on your team gets easier once you’ve looked honestly at what drives your own decisions, and it puts you in a much better position to model the change you’re asking for.

Help Your Team Examine Theirs

Listen for comments like “That never works here” or “Management won’t listen anyway.” They usually reflect real experiences that have shaped what employees expect, and they can reveal more about what motivates individuals on your team than a survey would. Instead of dismissing those comments, ask what led to them. The answers may point to organizational practices that need to change before anyone’s beliefs can.

Then give people a chance to experience something different. If employees believe their ideas get ignored, act on one and show them how it influenced a decision. Those experiences matter beyond motivation, too. People who feel their efforts go nowhere tend to disengage, which is why belief plays such a big role in employee retention rates.

When Culture Resists Change

Over time, individual beliefs can harden into shared assumptions that shape how a whole team behaves. If a leader assumes employees resist every new initiative, they may stop asking for input and roll out changes without discussion. Employees learn their input isn’t expected, so when the next initiative arrives, the response is predictable: “We’ve tried something like this before.” What started as one leader’s assumption has become the team’s expectation.

Gallup finds that managers account for 70% of the variance in team engagement, which gives leaders real influence over which beliefs take hold. Changing the pattern means showing that a different outcome is possible, both by inviting participation and by making sure employees see their contributions reflected in real decisions. As those experiences add up, the team’s values and beliefs start to support change instead of working against it.

How Mark J. Panciera Helps Leaders and Teams Change

I’ve watched plenty of leaders and teams leave a workshop fired up to do things differently, only to slide back into old habits a few weeks later. Usually, it’s because they’re still operating from the same beliefs that shaped their old behavior.

That’s why my approach begins by helping people recognize what they believe about themselves and what’s possible for them.

My keynotes and speaking engagements help leaders and teams identify the assumptions behind their decisions and see how those beliefs affect their performance. For some, that means confronting personal doubts that have held them back for years. For others, it’s recognizing how their leadership shapes the people around them, or how shared beliefs have come to define their company culture.

With a Mindset Reset, people leave with a clearer sense of what they’re capable of and a practical way to act on it. That awareness is the key to making change last for good.

Change the Belief, Change the Behavior

Knowing what motivates people to change behavior can help you get change started. Keeping it going depends on what people believe about themselves and what they’re capable of, and that includes you. When leaders examine their own beliefs and help their teams do the same, meaningful change can finally become sustainable.

Ready to look at the beliefs behind the behaviors you’re trying to change? Connect with Mark J. Panciera to book a keynote or consultation for your leaders and teams.

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes, people can change their behavior without changing their underlying beliefs, but those changes rarely last. While external rewards or consequences encourage changes, keeping them going becomes difficult when old assumptions continue influencing their decisions. Once a belief shifts, the new behavior becomes much easier to maintain.

What drives people to change is a mix of internal desires and external influences, such as personal goals, dissatisfaction with the status quo, new opportunities, and meaningful rewards. Whether they keep those changes often depends on what they believe about their own abilities when challenges come up.

Curiosity, personal growth, and the possibility of new experiences are among the things that motivate people to explore unfamiliar situations. Their willingness to act also depends on how they perceive uncertainty. Someone who believes they can learn from new experiences may approach the unknown with greater confidence.

Common employee motivators include meaningful work, competitive compensation, recognition, professional development, and opportunities for advancement. However, understanding what motivates individuals also requires considering their beliefs about leadership, workplace expectations, and personal capabilities. Employees are more likely to stay engaged when they believe their contributions matter and their efforts can lead to meaningful progress.

There is no universal timeline for changing behavior. Some habits take longer to develop than others, and progress often depends on how easily a new behavior fits into someone’s daily routine. Forming a habit can take anywhere from several weeks to several months, so it’s important to allow time to adjust and recognize that occasional setbacks are a normal part of the process.

The most effective way to change behavior is to look beyond what motivates people to change behavior and instead examine the beliefs behind their actions. When people challenge the assumptions that have held them back, they can approach change with more confidence and build habits that support their long-term goals.

Share This Article

Mark Panciera

Mark Panciera is an accomplished business owner, entrepreneur, author, and executive advisor recognized for his work in mindset transformation, leadership, and human performance. Through his A4 MINDSET RESET MODEL — Awareness, Acceptance, Action, and Achievement — he helps leaders identify limiting beliefs and understand how to leverage mindset for stronger, measurable results. A TED Talk presenter with more than 1.5 million views and a Vistage Top Speaker Award winner, Mark has worked with leaders and organizations across business, healthcare, education, government, and athletics. His insights have been featured by CNBC, Forbes, The New York Times, USA Today, Inc. Magazine, and other national media.

Others Categories

Move From Insight to Measurable Results

Connect with Mark to explore how these insights can be applied to your leadership, team, or organization.